Online Payments

Schultheis Insurance gladly accepts clients’ payments at any of our convenient locations, by phone, or online. In addition, many insurance carriers offer convenient phone or online premium payment options. Click on the links below to make direct payments.

Accident Fund Insurance

Acuity Insurance

AmeriSafe Insurance

Auto Owners Insurance

Cincinnati Insurance

Continental Western Insurance

Eastern Alliance Insurance

Encova/ Brick Street

Foremost Insurance

Hartford Insurance

Hastings Mutual Insurance

ICW Group Insurance

Illinois Casualty Insurance

Indiana Farmers Insurance

IPFS Insurance

Jewelers Mutual Insurance

Kentucky Employers Mutual Insurance (KEMI)

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Markel/ First Comp Insurance

Mennonite Mutual Insurance

Pekin Insurance

Progressive Insurance

Safeco Insurance

Secura Insurance

Selective Insurance

State Auto Insurance

Travelers Insurance

USLI Insurance

West Bend Mutual Insurance

Zurich Insurance