Top

Schultheis Insurance

For What Matters Most

  • Schultheis Insurance - Celebrating 80 years - Three generations of personal service.

Welcome to Schultheis Insurance

Schultheis Insurance is a well-established independent insurance agency located in Evansville, IN, proudly serving Greenwood, Mt. Vernon, Newburgh, and the surrounding areas. For over 70 years, we’ve built a reputation for providing high-quality, cost-effective insurance products and exceptional service. As an independent agency, we partner with over 150 insurance providers, enabling us to offer our customers competitive rates on a wide range of personal and commercial insurance solutions.

At Schultheis Insurance, our experienced insurance agents are dedicated to helping you find the perfect coverage for your needs. Whether you’re looking for a quote on auto insurance or need assistance with an insurance claim, we are here to guide you every step of the way. Our commitment to excellent service means we’ve been there when our customers needed us, and we’ll be there for you too.

Contact Us

Call or Email Schultheis

800-635-4661

info@schultheis.net

WE’RE BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS

LEARN ABOUT US
GET A QUOTE

Schultheis Insurance Offers a Range of Specialized Insurance Products

Auto Insurance

Auto Insurance

Car & Truck
Motorcycle
Boat
RV
Aviation

More About Auto
Home Insurance

Home Insurance

Homeowners
Renters
Flood
Personal Property
Umbrella

More About Home
Life Insurance

Life Insurance

Term Life
Whole Life
Universal Life
Senior Whole Life
Children’s Whole Life

More About Life
Health Insurance

Health Insurance

For Individuals
For Family
For Groups
Disability
Vision
Dental

More About Health
Business Insurance

Business Insurance

Commercial Property
Commercial Auto
General Liability
Workers Compensation
Commercial Umbrella
Cyber Security

More About Business

Latest News & Helpful Articles

  • Avoid the cost and hassle of leaks by installing a water shut-off device.

    Vacation water leak nightmare… times two

    By Cincinnati Personal Lines They say that homes that experience one water loss are likely to experience more. Steve Leibel, a Cincinnati Insurance vice president and personal lines risk manager, found that was true when two separate water heater leaks occurred in his home while his family was on vacation. The flood The first incident […]


    Read More»

What Our Clients Are SayINg

Schultheis Can Handle It

I highly recommend Schultheis Insurance for all of your insurance needs.

The Schultheis team is extremely professional, helpful, available and really understands the needs of their client.

They handle both my personal and business insurance and I could not be more satisfied.

 

Jeffrey Greenberg

We Couldn’t Be More Pleased

We have had Schultheis Insurance for several years now. Shelley Conyer is our agent and we couldn’t be more pleased with the customer service she provides. She’s very responsive, pleasant and professional. She always takes care of our needs in a very timely matter. I would refer her to anyone. I’ve never had anyone that provides service as well as Shelley. We are very pleased.

David & Leanne Guerrettaz

A Great Business Partner

For over 20 years now, we have partnered with Schultheis for all of our business policy needs. Their service, knowledge, and dependability have been invaluable in keeping our business and employees safe while also managing costs. Whether it be analyzing current/future needs in our policies or guiding us through a claims process, they are with us every step of the way. As a 3rd generation family-owned small business ourselves, we know they understand the challenges we face and feel secure in knowing they always have our best interests at heart.

The Extra Mile

We have been clients of Schultheis Insurance for over 40 years. Shelley is always willing to go the extra mile for us. She calls you back in a timely manner, finds the best policies for the price, and is very friendly and helpful when you need advice on various types of insurance. If she doesn’t have the answers to your questions, she will do her research and get back to you. We highly recommend Schultheis Insurance and Shelley for all your insurance needs.

Bernard Klein

A Family Owned Business

We have been doing business with Schultheis for over a decade. We love working with a family owned business. No matter who we’ve worked with, we feel like we have a close connection with professionals who take care of you like you’re a part of their family. They are responsive, honest and reliable and I can’t imagine doing business with anyone besides Brett and his wonderful team!

Reanna Moore - Owner
Ahh Spa & Ahh Spa Academy
MORE TESTIMONIALS

OUR MISSION

Established in 1944 as a family-owned and operated business, Schultheis Insurance is an independent insurance agency dedicated to offering our clients the best value on the most dependable, high quality insurance and financial products that fit their needs, and providing around-the-clock claim service.

Start a quote

At Schultheis Insurance, we are more than just an insurance provider—we are your trusted partner in safeguarding what matters most. Contact us today to learn more about our comprehensive insurance solutions and request a personalized quote. Don't wait—ensure your peace of mind with Schultheis Insurance.

We believe that every new policy begins with a relationship with a trusted advisor. Our agents are trained to work with you to get you the coverage you need as well as educate you on the products available.

Name(Required)

What types of insurance do you need?

Auto
Home
Life
Business
Health
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.